Sunday, 1 January 2017

Imponderables

Alan Moore, Jerusalem. See here.

Can an author write about experiences that are not his? Can a man write from the point of view of a woman giving birth? Read "The Breeze That Plucks The Apron." (pp. 263-292) Of course, a woman reader might say that I as a male reader cannot know whether Alan Moore as a male writer has got it right. We can only make our own assessments of the veracity of what we read.

"'...turning all that money down.'" (p. 267)

Those five words sound autobiographical?

The midwife makes the point that, if May had been rich, then she would not have married Tom and therefore would not have been having this child. See If Not. We cannot assess different versions of our lives or, e.g., compare the children that we would have had with different wives or husbands. Fortunately, we do not have to.

Simultaneity

Doctor Manhattan:

"Time is simultaneous, an intricately structured jewel that humans insist on viewing one edge at a time, when the whole design is visible in every facet."
-Alan Moore, Watchmen (London, 1987), Chapter IX, p. 6.

Comments:

(i) Time is simultaneous? All times are the same time? Contradiction?

(ii) We do not insist on our view of time. We find that we have this view.

(iii) If there is something that we view one edge at a time, then it exists at those different times at which we view it. Thus, our viewing is temporal even if the thing viewed is static.

Snowy Vernall, knowing what will happen to his wife fifty years hence, reflects:

"That, of course, was all in the now-then, while down beneath him in the now-now he could hear..."
-Alan Moore, Jerusalem (London, 2016), p. 253.

Usually, we divide times into now (this time) and then (any other time). Vernall has reduced all times to now but immediately reintroduces a distinction between now and then. However, his thought in this passage is not quite the same as Doctor Manhattan's. Vernall's "now-now" simply means "the moment in which I am thinking this" whereas Manhattan definitely introduces a second temporal dimension with his "...one edge at a time."

Angles

Alan Moore, Jerusalem (London, 2016).

Physically, all that happens in "Do As You Darn Well Pleasey" (pp. 243-261) is that mad John "Snowy" Vernall stands on a rooftop in Lambeth, London, while his wife gives birth on the street below. I think that we have met their daughter as an adult although I have not checked back and forth to confirm how many generations we are dealing with.

Vernall is conscious of each moment in that moment even though he also sees along the temporal dimension. He does not experience his entire world-line from birth to death in a single atemporal instant and, if he did, then he would not experience it because an experience that began and ended simultaneously would not exist. It would be the temporal equivalent of a perfectly flat plane with zero depth, a mathematical abstraction, not a concrete reality.

Vernall quotes, "Non Angli, sed Angeli," a phrase that we have met before. See here and here.

Saturday, 31 December 2016

Reflections On Earlier Reading

Alan Moore, Jerusalem (London, 2016).

One conversation between two people is one event but two experiences. This was never more clearly shown than in the two accounts of the encounter between Marla and Ben. We have no idea of what is going on inside Ben when all that we have read is Marla's experience of their brief bizarre dialogue.

"Chaotic" and "embedded" (see here) seem contradictory but I am sure that they are thesis and antithesis although the synthesis, reality perceived and understood as both dynamic and complete, eludes me. Each person is simultaneously a part of the totality and a part of its self-consciousness but only a part. As yet, I know only seven chapters of this million-word novel although the rest of the text already exists, stretching ahead of me from p. 245 to p. 1174. Right now, most of 2017 also stretches ahead of us. I am certain that it is real although not that it is present - but I am about to read about Snowy Vernall's "...glimpse of the elusive fourth plane, the fourth axis, which was time." (p. 245)

Happy New Year.

"Embedded In The Future"

Snowy Vernall in Jerusalem shares the perspective of Doctor Manhattan in Watchmen:

"The chaotic childbirth onto the South London cobbles couldn't be avoided; was embedded in the future."
-Alan Moore, Jerusalem (London, 2016), p. 244.

"Some marble blocks have statues within them, embedded in their future."
-Alan Moore, Watchmen (London, 1987), Chapter IV, p. 24.

Also, on Mars:

"It's called chaotic terrain." Chapter IX, p. 14.

"To distill so specific a form from that chaos of improbability, like turning air to gold... That is the crowning unlikelihood. The thermodynamic miracle." Chapter IX, p. 27.

Chaos, childbirth and embedding in the future are common to these texts. "Jerusalem" evokes the Bible and Blake. "Watchmen" evokes Plato and Juvenal.

"Alan Moore is the Watchman on the walls of civilization."
-Kathy Acker, quoted on the back of Voice Of The Fire.

Endings

This image shows the "monoliths," mentioned here.

Alan Moore, Jerusalem (London, 2016).

The Prelude, "Work in Progress," ends with Alma's exhibition about to begin. This is indeed a prelude.

"A Host of Angles" ends with Ern's death, a closure.

"ASBOs of Desire" ends with a cliff-hanger:

"She walked towards the car." (p. 93)

"Rough Sleepers" ends with anticipation:

"This looked like it was going to turn out to be quite a night." (p. 123)

"X Marks the Spot" ends with the monk Peter's death and last word, another closure.

"Modern Times" ends with anticipation or apprehension:

"Somewhere not too far away, he hoped, an audience was waiting. The gas mantle hissed a dismal premonition." (p. 173)

"Blind, but Now I See" ends with a revelation.

"Atlantis" ends with another cliff-hanger as Ben tries to return to writing poetry:

"His right hand trembled, inches from the snow-blind, empty page." (p. 241)

That is as far as I have read but it is a great deal of human life and death already, to say the least.

Friday, 30 December 2016

Monoliths, Beamed Down

Alan Moore, Jerusalem (London, 2016).

OK. Ben has met Marla (see here) and we have found out what happened to her. We knew that she had got into a car and we think now that she was in the crashed car but it is something else. Ben reminds me of our Ben in Lancaster who is an amdram merchant, not a published poet.

Alan Moore's Ben recalls a historical miracle that sounds familiar from Voice Of The Fire although I am not about to check it out at this time of night after watching an episode of Arrow, then reading more of Jerusalem.

This is good - two tower blocks are:

"...black as Stanley Kubrick monoliths, beamed down by an unfathomable alien intelligence..." (p. 239)

Two sf screen references right beside each other. Monoliths, beamed down. We all understand it. And it is just two blocks of flats. But Ben, who thinks the comparison, is a published poet, of course.

Addendum: See comments below.