Sunday 23 June 2019

Stieg Larsson's Millennium Trilogy From Page To Screen

Scenes are left out, shortened or changed. I am not going to conduct an exhaustive analysis.

In the first book, Blomkvist visits his ex-wife and daughter, then visits his sister and her family, then is rung by Frode at the Millennium office whereas, on TV, the ex-wife and daughter are not mentioned and Blomkvist is rung by Frode while visiting his sister.

A necklace inherited from Anita was introduced on TV as a way of differentiating between Cecilia and Anita in a single photograph. In the book, Blomkvist had seen what he thought was a single woman in many group photos before he found another photo showing two almost identical women side by side. Also, Henrik Vanger had photos of Harriet's window open and closed, showing that someone had been in her room on the day when she disappeared. Then Blomkvist found a third photo with a face in the window. He thought that it was Cecilia although it turned out to be Anita. On TV, Henrik had the photo of the woman in the window and thought that it was Harriet. Then Blomkvist thought that it was Cecilia because the woman was wearing Cecilia's necklace but Cecilia said that she had inherited it from Anita.

In the book, Blomkvist visited Anita in London and traced her call to Harriet in Australia whereas, on TV, Anita was dead and Lisbeth discovered that there were two Anita Vangers, one dead, the other in Australia.

Blomkvist did not find a photo enabling him to identify Martin Vanger but instead broke into the old Nazi, Harald's, house and had to be rescued by Martin.

In the second book, the blond giant:

hallucinates;
runs when he sees Lisbeth resurrected;
is apprehended and tied up by Blomkvist;
but escapes when two cops come to collect him -

- whereas, on TV, he:

dodges when the resurrected Lizbeth fires at him;
runs when Blomkvist's car approaches.

Blomkvist had driven all the way, not gone by train first.

Blomkvist did not see Lizbeth attacked outside her flat and find the bag containing keys that she had dropped. Instead, Lizbeth visited Miriam in hospital and dropped the keys there.

Thursday 20 June 2019

The Structure Of A Series: Dornford Yates IV

See here.

After further reading and rereading, I think that the second group of Chandos and related novels should be reorganized thus:

Safe Custody
Shoal Water
Adele and Co.
Storm Music
Cost Price
Gale Warning
Red In The Morning
Ne'er-Do-Well

The four volumes that feature Falcon of Scotland Yard are:

Period Stuff
Red In The Morning
The House That Berry Built
Ne'er Do Well

Jenny is prominent as Mrs Chandos in:

Cost Price
Gale Warning
Red In The Morning
The Berry Scene
Ne'er Do Well 

See Bibliography.

Wednesday 19 June 2019

The Structure Of A Series: Dornford Yates III

Dornford Yates' ten Berry books subdivide not into two fives but into a six and a four.

1914-1936
The Brother Of Daphne (1914), pre-War
The Courts Of Idleness (1920), before, during and after WWI
Berry and Co. (1921)
Jonah and Co. (1922)
Adele and Co. (1931)
And Berry Came Too (1936)

I am currently rereading Yates so might have to revise some of these statements. And Berry Came Too is set during a summer between two chapters of Berry and Co. (or something). The theme is upper class life in the period that we recognize as between the Wars.

1945-1958
The House That Berry Built (1945), War approaches, ancestral home sold
The Berry Scene (1947), a review of the whole period
As Berry And I Were Saying (1952)
B-Berry And I Look Back (1958)

The last two are memoirs which step outside the fictional continuity.

Tuesday 18 June 2019

The Structure Of A Series: Dornford Yates II

In the preceding post, we summarized the first six Chandos books:

Blind Corner
Perishable Goods
Blood Royal
Fire Below
She Fell Among Thieves
An Eye For A Tooth 

Because An Eye For A Tooth is an immediate sequel to Blind Corner and thus an extended flashback, this sequence of six novels chronologically ends with She Fell Among Thieves and thus with Richard Chandos' engagement to Jenny. (George Hanbury, having died between Fire Below and She Fell Among Thieves, is seen alive again, but for the last time, in An Eye For A Tooth.)

The remaining two Chandos books, Red In The Morning and Cost Price, form a sequence with five other novels by Yates:

in Safe Custody, because Mansel had killed "Rose" Noble in Perishable Goods, the thug, Punter, now works for Harris who dies trying to steal the treasure of Hohenems;

in Shoal Water, Mansel defeats The Shepherd, a patron of the thieves' kitchen, The Wet Flag;

in Adele And Co., Mansel and his cousins defeat Daniel Gedge, another patron of The Wet Flag;

Gale Warning (see the previous post) ends with Richard and Jenny Chandos and Mansel on holiday in Freilles, France;

Red In The Morning begins in Freilles where Mansel and Chandos encounter Punter, then Gedge, the former now working for the latter, and Mansel also meets Toby Rage who had appeared in "Toby" and in "Childish Things" and will later appear in The Berry Scene;

in Cost Price, Punter informs another thief, Friar, of the Hohenems treasure but Mansel and Chandos intervene;

in Ne'er-Do-Well, Chief Inspector (now Superintendent) Falcon, who also appears in four short stories in Period Stuff, informs Mansel, Chandos and Jenny of one of his investigations. Falcon is also in Red In The Morning and The House That Berry Built.

Adele And Co. is one of the ten Berry books narrated by Boy Pleydell.

(There is a British consular official called Pleydell-Smith in Ian Fleming's Doctor No.)

Monday 17 June 2019

The Structure Of A Series: Dornford Yates

(I am currently rereading Dornford Yates' novels after a gap of about fifty five years so some of what I write here might have to be revised.)

In Gale Warning:

Jonathan Mansel, Richard Chandos and George St. Omer have been fighting crime outside the law for a while;

the mastermind, Barabbas, organizes the murder of St. Omer;

however, St. Omer's friend, John Bagot, joins Mansel and Chandos and helps them to bring down Barabbas;

Chandos' wife is called "Jenny."

You might deduce from this account that Gale Warning had been preceded by several earlier volumes of a Mansel/Chandos/St. Omer series? Instead, it was preceded by six Chandos books that gradually paved the way for the situation as described in Gale Warning.

The Opening Diptych (= Two Volumes)
In Blind Corner, Mansel, Chandos and George Hanbury (not St. Omer) defeat "Rose" Nobel and appropriate buried treasure.
In Perishable Goods, Mansel, Chandos and Hanbury defeat a kidnapping and blackmail attempt by Noble and Mansel kills Noble.

A Second Diptych
In Blood Royal and Fire Below, Chandos and Hanbury, without Mansel, have adventures in a fictional European country and both wind up married.

Two Further Novels
In She Fell Among Thieves:

Mansel is back;
but Hanbury, Hanbury's wife and Chandos' first wife have died;
Chandos meets and will marry Jenny.

An Eye For A Tooth:

is a flashback sequel to Blind Corner, set before Perishable Goods;
therefore, shows Hanbury still alive;
retroactively transforms the opening diptych into a trilogy.

That leaves only two Chandos Books, Red In The Morning and Cost Price, set after Chandos has married Jenny and they are also set after Gale Warning. There are other complications to be addressed later.

Mansel And Chandos

Eight listed "'Chandos' Books" by Dornford Yates feature and are narrated by Richard Chandos.

Chandos also narrates a ninth novel, Ne'er-Do-Well, and appears in a tenth, Gale Warning.

Thus, for present purposes, we can refer to ten Chandos books.

Jonathan Mansel is:

"'Jonah' in Yates' ten "'Berry' Books" and in one other "Berry" short story, "Letters Patent";

"Mansel" in eight of the ten Chandos books and in two other novels, Shoal Water and Gale Warning.

Mansel's and Chandos' antagonist, "Punter," appears in the related novel, Safe Custody.

The ninth and tenth 'Berry' books and "Letters Patent" are set in an alternative continuity, where:

Mansel's cousin, Boy Pleydell, the narrator of the 'Berry' books -

has, like Cecil William Mercer (Dornford Yates), worked as a barrister;
thus, has not always been a "man of leisure";
wrote the "Dornford Yates" books, including the Chandos novels, as works of fiction under that pen name.

Addendum:Boy was also a barrister in The Berry Scene.

Saturday 15 June 2019

Dornford Yates

After a gap of over fifty years, I am rereading Dornford Yates' Chandos books and reading his non-series thrillers.

Richard Chandos narrates eight Chandos books and Boy Pleydell narrates ten Berry books.

Jonah in the Berry Books is Mansel in the Chandos Books and other thrillers.

Inspector Falcon features in some short stories and in Ne-er-Do-Well narrated by Chandos and guest-starring Mansel.

The Chandos book, Red In The Morning, is a sequel to the Berry book, Adele and Co, and to the non-series thriller, Gale Warning.

 The Chandos book, Cost Price, is a sequel to the non-series thriller, Safe Custody.

Mansel appears in Shoal Water; Mansel and Chandos in Gale Warning.

There are other connections.